|Israel Retaliates Against Hamas in Gaza - Not Quite a Surgical Strike|
We'll preface our remarks by noting that we don't take sides with either Hamas or Israel in this conflict. We find the actions of both reprehensible.
Lest we be categorized as neophytes in this discussion, please note that we made our reputation within the US Intelligence and Military communities in the Counter-Insurgency and the Counter-Terror arenas, including conducting a successful counter-insurgency campaign in Asia, and later accurately analyzing and assessing anti-government political movements in Eastern Europe and Latin America. We spent time in the Middle East, meeting with IDF and Mossad officers, and with US Intelligence officers monitoring events in Israel and contributed to an NIE on Israeli intentions. We have, for the last 20 years, consulted on global threats to US interests, and most recently, created a course on Counter-Terrorism -- the basis of which is "Understanding the Terrorist and His Motives".
All told, we have about 40 years of hands-on experience in this field, and have been recognized and rewarded by the SSCI, the DCI, and the CJCS for our expertise and accomplishments.
ISRAEL HAS ADVANTAGES:
1) Technical Intelligence ProgramsIsrael has one of the most sophisticated intel programs in the world:
a) Electronically, it has hacked into the US DoD Intelligence Information System [DODIIS]
b) It created the Stuxnet and Flame viruses which disrupted the Iranian nuclear research program [but, it also managed to escape into the ether, posing a global IT threat].
2) Seismic Sensor Detection SystemIsrael also has one of the most sophisticated sound and seismic sensor detection systems in the world, which allows it to detect the construction of tunnels, and the pitter-patter of little feet -- and construction equipment, deep underground. These technologies have been around since the Vietnam War and were quite sophisticated then, and we used them quite effectively to monitor the VietCong and other insurgent movements.
-- It is unrealistic to think that Israel would ignore that technology in a hostile environment.
3) MossadMossad is Israel's version of the CIA -- one of the most sophisticated HUMINT espionage programs which successfully targeted every ally and potential adversary in the world [to include the US -- Jonathan Pollard springs to mind].
It strains credulity to understand why Israel fears the impact of the tunnels Hamas has been building. We wonder how Israel could have been unaware of the construction of the tunnels, to include their precise origins in Gaza and their precise entries into Israel's territory. It would also seem obvious that Israel should have been fully aware of every threat against it in Gaza by Hamas, to include the sourcing, delivery, and placement of every rocket launching site.
And, with the Iron Dome detection and protective canopy, are we to believe that these rockets pose more than an ethereal threat? Israel brags that with the Iron Dome, the threat is minimal, and we believe that statement, given the casualty figures. The number of Israeli casualties from these rockets is three civilians; and 63 IDF soldiers have been killed in direct combat; in Gaza, more than 1,650 Palestinians -- mostly civilians -- women and children, have been killed by Israeli assault.
So, with all that intelligence, why did Israel not simply manage their assault through these tunnels, and use smart bombs for surgical strikes on the storage bins.
Instead, there has been massive aerial and ground artillery bombardment of the entire area, supplemented by missiles and naval bombardment. These assaults have been followed by tanks and armored vehicles rolling through Gaza, supplemented by snipers in a mop-up exercise.
The latest development is that Israel has called up 16,000 reservists to boost its total to 86,000.
Is it possible to squeeze any more troops into Gaza?
TO SUMMARIZE:Israel has one of the most sophisticated intelligence programs in the world with:
1) superb electronic, sound and intrusion detection capabilities
2) the full resources of the NSA [which it successfully hacked long ago] and which NSA openly shares with Israel
3) the full resources of the DOD Intelligence Information System [which it hacked long ago]
4) the US satellite monitoring system
[the detailed elements which Jonathan Pollard provided to Mossad]
5) Plus, it has the Iron Dome to detect and neutralize incoming rockets.
Now, with all those resources, how are we to believe that a bunch of Hamas operatives, shooting off rockets toward Israel could not be detected ahead of time, and that Israel was incapable of locating, monitoring, and destroying the tunnels, supply systems, and the rocket launch sites.
Given those advantages, why would it be necessary for Israel to demolish all of Gaza, with the massive loss of life of close to 2,000 non-combatants, including women and children. We wonder also at Israel's bombardment of schools and UN refugee safe-havens. Were it any other country, the US Media would be screaming bloody murder -- and it is, literally, bloody murder.
We recall the stated objective of the former Israeli Prime Minister, Ariel Sharon, a general we admired for his extraordinary military accomplishments, to champion the construction of Israeli settlements in the West Bank and the Gaza Strip -- displacing the Palestinians living there. Palestinians referred to him as The Butcher who routinely created confrontations with Palestinians which would justify his use of extreme force; these included the Qibya Massacre  and the Shatila and Sabre Massacre . Sharon remained immune from prosecution as his officers who volunteered to testify against him all suffered Breitbart Moments when their cars mysteriously exploded.
Some may recall the Palestinian's Second Intifada [uprising] which resulted from Sharon sending 1,000 of his troops into the most sacred Muslim al-Aqsa Mosque on the Noble Sanctuary [aka: the Dome of the Rock] in Jerusalem; this would be the equivalent of the Italian government sending 1,000 armed Carabinieri into Saint Peter's Cathedral in the Vatican.
[Notably, Israeli troops again stormed the Mosque in mid-July.]
Having riled up the Palestinians with this outrage, Sharon soundly defeated them and won political points with the Israelis for "protecting" them against the crazy, bloodthirsty Palestinians.
|Israel has gradually consumed all but a small portion of what originally constituted Palestine|
We refer again to the Israeli version of Manifest Destiny, in which the Palestinians are displaced to make room for Israeli settlers. Former Prime Minister Ariel Sharon, a brilliant general and architect of the Israeli Manifest Destiny program, created confrontations and battles with the Palestinians to justify driving Palestinians from their land so Israelis could settle there. His proclaimed targets were the West Bank and Gaza where he projected the construction of Israeli settlements.
West Bank of Israelis.
For this widely hailed and very popular effort to create a peaceful solution to the chronic hostilities, Sharon was attacked by his own Party, the Likud, which he left to form his own Party, Kadima - a major threat to the Likud's power.
Oddly, Sharon then met with a sudden Breitbart-Moment and suffered a stroke in 2006, which put him in a permanent vegetative state. Conspiracy theorists say that Shimon Peres orchestrated the "stroke" to eliminate Sharon's consolidation of power with a new political Party, which could have forced the end of Israel's Manifest Destiny.
But, that's all internal politics for Israel, and we should leave them to their own destiny.
Now, we do take issue with Israel meddling in US politics, even when they target folks who we dislike. If the politician is a corrupt dirtbag, he is OUR dirtbag, and it is not acceptable for brother Netanyahu or AIPAC to decide the fate of our dirtbags -- or, our foreign policy.
Jim Moran, a popular Congressman [D] in Northern Virginia, once made the mistake of criticizing Israel's role in drawing the US into war with Iraq in 2003. He was immediately pilloried as being anti-Semitic by the News Media, and even by his own Party. Already vulnerable following a series of behavioral issues, Moran found himself a target of The Washington Post and local TV News commentaries which threatened to end his political career. Thus, he embarked on a tour of synagogues throughout the area offering his mea culpas and swearing his allegiance to Israel.
Rumor has it that AIPAC gained control of Congress through our aid program, general and military, which has funneled roughly $60 billion into Israel over the last ten years. And, what becomes of all that cash? Some say that Israel funnels it back to the US, into AIPAC and a broad range of Israeli lobbying groups, the folks who are always ready with a fistful of "facts", snide remarks, ridicule, and innuendo -- and of course, the ubiquitous sobriquets of "anti-Semitism" for non-Jewish critics.
But, all that money doesn't just go to fund attack groups; there's plenty left over to line the pockets of Congresspersons or Senators, particularly come campaign time. So, recognizing that a vote for financial aid to Israel is a guarantee of financial aid to the politician who "supports" Israel, savvy politicians [particularly poor ones] waddle up to that pork trough and guzzle it down, stopping only periodically to proclaim their loving support for Israel.
|AIPAC: "Self-Hating Jew"?|
His parody of Israel and its rather specious rationale for razing Gaze in its hapless search for tunnels and evil-doers resulted in such a massive verbal onslaught that he was stunned, particularly when he was warned by the network hierarchy that his program was at risk should he again poke fun at Israel. Pretty heavy stuff -- putting fear into an extremely popular TV host -- of all things, a comedy show.
So, we wish Gazans the best of luck in resisting Israeli bombers, bulldozers, and settlers. Your elected Hamas leadership has been manipulated into creating the scenario by which Israel can justify its assault on Gaza, and that has, unfortunately for you, become a self-destructive cause.
Don't look to the US for sympathy or assistance. You just don't understand how to exploit American political corruption. If you did, you'd be pulling in $60 billion in aid as well and bribing US politicians with it, vs taking a sharp stick in the eye and listening to European platitudes.